Critique

[joe_elway]

The reason we are here is to learn from each other.  This mean that we have to receive and give constructive criticism.

Giving critique is important.  It's great to hear "fantastic shot" from people if you've actually taken something special (admittedly a rare enough moment for me).  But what we're really after is someone teaching us something new so we can learn from our mistakes.  If there is something you like about a photo then say what it is.  If there is something you don't like then constructively say what it is.

This is a two way street.  Not only must people comment on the photo but the poster must be mature enough to accept that maybe someone else can teach them something new or have a different or fresh perspective.

We're trying to create a community here.  It's natural that certain people will gravitate to each other.  But lets not allow that to prevent us from commenting on other peoples photos.  You shouldn't feel like you cannot comment on a post because you're new or because you don't know the poster.  Feel free to say your piece if you have something constructive to say.

And let's help out the newbies, not only to photography but to different types of photography.  We all realise that time is finite, but if you see a photo with zero comments, it might be a nice sentiment to go in and say something.  We're not saying you have to spend your day doing this but if we all make an effort then the sense of community will reinforced.

Finally, be mature folks!  Be constructive.  Do not critique other people's criticisms.  Don't launch personal attacks.  If you have a problem with someone then we suggest you act like a civilised adult and take it up with them personally or keep it to yourself.